Dashboard Schema V2: Fix public dashboards and snapshots (#110060)

* wip; public dashboards and snapshots work

* Chore: Fix example of major release (#110007)

baldm0mma/ fix example of major release

* CI: Push docker images to dockerhub on merges to main (#110056)

* support extracting queries in schema V2

* fix lint and test

* fix test

* clean up

* clean up

* apply feedback about early returns

* fix url issue when clicking open original dashboard in v1

* refactor to early returns

* fix api version comparison

---------

Co-authored-by: Jev Forsberg <46619047+baldm0mma@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Kevin Minehart <5140827+kminehart@users.noreply.github.com>
This commit is contained in:
Haris Rozajac
2025-09-10 13:09:37 -06:00
committed by GitHub
co-authored by Jev Forsberg Kevin Minehart
parent 7c0a44579c
commit 11898abccb
6 changed files with 462 additions and 24 deletions
@@ -159,6 +159,12 @@ func (pd *PublicDashboardServiceImpl) GetQueryDataResponse(ctx context.Context,
// buildMetricRequest merges public dashboard parameters with dashboard and returns a metrics request to be sent to query backend
func (pd *PublicDashboardServiceImpl) buildMetricRequest(dashboard *dashboards.Dashboard, publicDashboard *models.PublicDashboard, panelID int64, reqDTO models.PublicDashboardQueryDTO) (dtos.MetricRequest, error) {
isV2 := dashboard.Data.Get("elements").Interface() != nil
if isV2 {
return pd.buildMetricRequestV2(dashboard, publicDashboard, panelID, reqDTO)
}
// group queries by panel
queriesByPanel := groupQueriesByPanelId(dashboard.Data)
queries, ok := queriesByPanel[panelID]
@@ -183,6 +189,31 @@ func (pd *PublicDashboardServiceImpl) buildMetricRequest(dashboard *dashboards.D
}, nil
}
func (pd *PublicDashboardServiceImpl) buildMetricRequestV2(dashboard *dashboards.Dashboard, publicDashboard *models.PublicDashboard, panelID int64, reqDTO models.PublicDashboardQueryDTO) (dtos.MetricRequest, error) {
// group queries by panel for V2
queriesByPanel := groupQueriesByPanelIdV2(dashboard.Data)
queries, ok := queriesByPanel[panelID]
if !ok {
return dtos.MetricRequest{}, models.ErrPanelNotFound.Errorf("buildMetricRequestV2: public dashboard panel not found")
}
ts := buildTimeSettingsV2(dashboard, reqDTO, publicDashboard, panelID)
// determine safe resolution to query data at
safeInterval, safeResolution := pd.getSafeIntervalAndMaxDataPoints(reqDTO, ts)
for i := range queries {
queries[i].Set("intervalMs", safeInterval)
queries[i].Set("maxDataPoints", safeResolution)
queries[i].Set("queryCachingTTL", reqDTO.QueryCachingTTL)
}
return dtos.MetricRequest{
From: ts.From,
To: ts.To,
Queries: queries,
}, nil
}
func groupQueriesByPanelId(dashboard *simplejson.Json) map[int64][]*simplejson.Json {
result := make(map[int64][]*simplejson.Json)
@@ -191,6 +222,89 @@ func groupQueriesByPanelId(dashboard *simplejson.Json) map[int64][]*simplejson.J
return result
}
func groupQueriesByPanelIdV2(dashboard *simplejson.Json) map[int64][]*simplejson.Json {
result := make(map[int64][]*simplejson.Json)
elementsMap := dashboard.Get("elements").MustMap()
for _, element := range elementsMap {
element := simplejson.NewFromAny(element)
var panelQueries []*simplejson.Json
hasExpression := panelHasAnExpressionSchemaV2(element)
// For schema v2, queries are nested in element.spec.data.spec.queries
spec := element.Get("spec")
if spec.Interface() == nil {
result[element.Get("spec").Get("id").MustInt64()] = panelQueries
continue
}
data := spec.Get("data")
if data.Interface() == nil {
result[element.Get("spec").Get("id").MustInt64()] = panelQueries
continue
}
dataSpec := data.Get("spec")
if dataSpec.Interface() == nil {
result[element.Get("spec").Get("id").MustInt64()] = panelQueries
continue
}
queries := dataSpec.Get("queries")
if queries.Interface() == nil {
result[element.Get("spec").Get("id").MustInt64()] = panelQueries
continue
}
for _, queryObj := range queries.MustArray() {
query := simplejson.NewFromAny(queryObj)
// Check if query is hidden (PanelQuery.spec.hidden)
panelQuerySpec := query.Get("spec")
if panelQuerySpec.Interface() == nil {
continue
}
if !hasExpression && panelQuerySpec.Get("hidden").MustBool() {
continue
}
// Extract the actual query from PanelQuery.spec.query
dataQueryKind := panelQuerySpec.Get("query")
if dataQueryKind.Interface() == nil {
continue
}
dataQuerySpec := dataQueryKind.Get("spec")
if dataQuerySpec.Interface() == nil {
continue
}
dataQuerySpec.Del("exemplar")
group := dataQueryKind.Get("group").MustString()
// if query target has no datasource, set it to have the datasource on the panel
if _, ok := dataQuerySpec.CheckGet("datasource"); !ok {
uid := getDataSourceUidFromJsonSchemaV2(dataQueryKind)
datasource := map[string]any{"type": group, "uid": uid}
dataQuerySpec.Set("datasource", datasource)
}
// We don't support exemplars for public dashboards currently
dataQuerySpec.Del("exemplar")
// The query object contains the DataQuery with the actual expression
panelQueries = append(panelQueries, dataQuerySpec)
}
result[element.Get("spec").Get("id").MustInt64()] = panelQueries
}
return result
}
func extractQueriesFromPanels(panels []any, result map[int64][]*simplejson.Json) {
for _, panelObj := range panels {
panel := simplejson.NewFromAny(panelObj)
@@ -242,6 +356,54 @@ func panelHasAnExpression(panel *simplejson.Json) bool {
return hasExpression
}
func panelHasAnExpressionSchemaV2(panel *simplejson.Json) bool {
var hasExpression bool
// For schema v2, check the nested structure: spec.data.spec.queries[].spec.query
spec := panel.Get("spec")
if spec.Interface() == nil {
return hasExpression
}
data := spec.Get("data")
if data.Interface() == nil {
return hasExpression
}
dataSpec := data.Get("spec")
if dataSpec.Interface() == nil {
return hasExpression
}
queries := dataSpec.Get("queries")
if queries.Interface() == nil {
return hasExpression
}
for _, queryObj := range queries.MustArray() {
query := simplejson.NewFromAny(queryObj)
// Navigate to the actual query object
querySpec := query.Get("spec")
if querySpec.Interface() == nil {
continue
}
queryData := querySpec.Get("query")
if queryData.Interface() == nil {
continue
}
// Check if this query is an expression
if expr.NodeTypeFromDatasourceUID(getDataSourceUidFromJsonSchemaV2(queryData)) == expr.TypeCMDNode {
hasExpression = true
break
}
}
return hasExpression
}
func getDataSourceUidFromJson(query *simplejson.Json) string {
uid := query.Get("datasource").Get("uid").MustString()
@@ -253,6 +415,18 @@ func getDataSourceUidFromJson(query *simplejson.Json) string {
return uid
}
func getDataSourceUidFromJsonSchemaV2(query *simplejson.Json) string {
// For schema v2, datasource info is in query.datasource
uid := query.Get("datasource").Get("name").MustString()
// before 8.3 special types could be sent as datasource (expr)
if uid == "" {
uid = query.Get("datasource").MustString()
}
return uid
}
func sanitizeMetadataFromQueryData(res *backend.QueryDataResponse) {
for k := range res.Responses {
frames := res.Responses[k].Frames
@@ -310,6 +484,28 @@ func buildTimeSettings(d *dashboards.Dashboard, reqDTO models.PublicDashboardQue
}
}
// buildTimeSettingsV2 builds time settings for V2 dashboards
func buildTimeSettingsV2(d *dashboards.Dashboard, reqDTO models.PublicDashboardQueryDTO, pd *models.PublicDashboard, panelID int64) models.TimeSettings {
from, to, timezone := getTimeRangeValuesOrDefaultV2(d, reqDTO, pd.TimeSelectionEnabled, panelID)
timeRange := NewTimeRange(from, to)
timeFrom, _ := timeRange.ParseFrom(
gtime.WithLocation(timezone),
)
timeTo, _ := timeRange.ParseTo(
gtime.WithLocation(timezone),
)
timeToAsEpoch := timeTo.UnixMilli()
timeFromAsEpoch := timeFrom.UnixMilli()
// Were using epoch ms because this is used to build a MetricRequest, which is used by query caching, which want the time range in epoch milliseconds.
return models.TimeSettings{
From: strconv.FormatInt(timeFromAsEpoch, 10),
To: strconv.FormatInt(timeToAsEpoch, 10),
}
}
// returns from, to and timezone from the request if the timeSelection is enabled or the dashboard default values
func getTimeRangeValuesOrDefault(reqDTO models.PublicDashboardQueryDTO, d *dashboards.Dashboard, timeSelectionEnabled bool, panelID int64) (string, string, *time.Location) {
from := d.Data.GetPath("time", "from").MustString()
@@ -344,6 +540,43 @@ func getTimeRangeValuesOrDefault(reqDTO models.PublicDashboardQueryDTO, d *dashb
return from, to, timezone
}
// getTimeRangeValuesOrDefaultV2 returns from, to and timezone from the request if the timeSelection is enabled or the dashboard default values for V2
func getTimeRangeValuesOrDefaultV2(d *dashboards.Dashboard, reqDTO models.PublicDashboardQueryDTO, timeSelectionEnabled bool, panelID int64) (string, string, *time.Location) {
// In V2, time settings are in dashboard.timeSettings
timeSettings := d.Data.Get("timeSettings")
from := timeSettings.Get("from").MustString()
to := timeSettings.Get("to").MustString()
dashboardTimezone := timeSettings.Get("timezone").MustString()
// Check for panel-specific time override in V2 structure
panelRelativeTime := getPanelRelativeTimeRangeV2(d.Data, panelID)
if panelRelativeTime != "" {
from = panelRelativeTime
}
// we use the values from the request if the time selection is enabled and the values are valid
if timeSelectionEnabled {
if reqDTO.TimeRange.From != "" && reqDTO.TimeRange.To != "" {
from = reqDTO.TimeRange.From
to = reqDTO.TimeRange.To
}
if reqDTO.TimeRange.Timezone != "" {
if userTimezone, err := time.LoadLocation(reqDTO.TimeRange.Timezone); err == nil {
return from, to, userTimezone
}
}
}
// if the dashboardTimezone is blank or there is an error default is UTC
timezone, err := time.LoadLocation(dashboardTimezone)
if err != nil {
return from, to, time.UTC
}
return from, to, timezone
}
func getPanelRelativeTimeRange(dashboard *simplejson.Json, panelID int64) string {
for _, panelObj := range dashboard.Get("panels").MustArray() {
panel := simplejson.NewFromAny(panelObj)
@@ -355,3 +588,51 @@ func getPanelRelativeTimeRange(dashboard *simplejson.Json, panelID int64) string
return ""
}
func getPanelRelativeTimeRangeV2(dashboard *simplejson.Json, panelID int64) string {
// In V2, check elements for panel-specific time settings
elements := dashboard.Get("elements")
if elements.Interface() == nil {
return ""
}
elementsMap := elements.MustMap()
for _, element := range elementsMap {
element := simplejson.NewFromAny(element)
// Check if this is the panel we're looking for
if element.Get("spec").Get("id").MustInt64() != panelID {
continue
}
// Check for time override in data.spec.queryOptions.timeFrom
spec := element.Get("spec")
if spec.Interface() == nil {
return ""
}
data := spec.Get("data")
if data.Interface() == nil {
return ""
}
dataSpec := data.Get("spec")
if dataSpec.Interface() == nil {
return ""
}
queryOptions := dataSpec.Get("queryOptions")
if queryOptions.Interface() == nil {
return ""
}
timeFrom := queryOptions.Get("timeFrom")
if timeFrom.Interface() != nil {
return timeFrom.MustString()
}
return ""
}
return ""
}
@@ -14,7 +14,7 @@ import {
AnnoKeyManagerKind,
AnnoKeySourcePath,
} from 'app/features/apiserver/types';
import { transformDashboardV2SpecToV1 } from 'app/features/dashboard/api/ResponseTransformers';
import { ensureV2Response, transformDashboardV2SpecToV1 } from 'app/features/dashboard/api/ResponseTransformers';
import { DashboardVersionError, DashboardWithAccessInfo } from 'app/features/dashboard/api/types';
import { isDashboardV2Resource, isDashboardV2Spec, isV2StoredVersion } from 'app/features/dashboard/api/utils';
import { dashboardLoaderSrv, DashboardLoaderSrvV2 } from 'app/features/dashboard/services/DashboardLoaderSrv';
@@ -408,6 +408,10 @@ export class DashboardScenePageStateManager extends DashboardScenePageStateManag
const rsp = await dashboardLoaderSrv.loadSnapshot(slug);
if (rsp?.dashboard) {
if (isDashboardV2Spec(rsp.dashboard)) {
throw new DashboardVersionError('v2beta1', 'Using legacy snapshot API to get a V2 dashboard');
}
const scene = transformSaveModelToScene(rsp);
return scene;
}
@@ -451,7 +455,14 @@ export class DashboardScenePageStateManager extends DashboardScenePageStateManag
case DashboardRoutes.Provisioning:
return this.loadProvisioningDashboard(slug || '', uid);
case DashboardRoutes.Public: {
return await dashboardLoaderSrv.loadDashboard('public', '', uid);
const result = await dashboardLoaderSrv.loadDashboard('public', '', uid);
// public dashboards use legacy API but can return V2 dashboards
// in this case we need to throw a dashboard version error so that the call can be delegated
// to V2 state manager which will run fetchDashboard
if (isDashboardV2Spec(result.dashboard)) {
throw new DashboardVersionError('v2beta1', 'Using legacy public dashboard API to get a V2 dashboard');
}
return result;
}
default:
// If reloadDashboardsOnParamsChange is on, we need to process query params for dashboard load
@@ -583,9 +594,10 @@ export class DashboardScenePageStateManagerV2 extends DashboardScenePageStateMan
public async loadSnapshotScene(slug: string): Promise<DashboardScene> {
const rsp = await this.dashboardLoader.loadSnapshot(slug);
const v2Response = ensureV2Response(rsp);
if (rsp?.spec) {
const scene = transformSaveModelSchemaV2ToScene(rsp);
if (v2Response.spec) {
const scene = transformSaveModelSchemaV2ToScene(v2Response);
return scene;
}
@@ -253,7 +253,7 @@ export function createDashboardSceneFromDashboardModel(oldModel: DashboardModel,
let annotationLayers: SceneDataLayerProvider[] = [];
let alertStatesLayer: AlertStatesDataLayer | undefined;
const uid = oldModel.uid;
const serializerVersion = config.featureToggles.dashboardNewLayouts ? 'v2' : 'v1';
const serializerVersion = config.featureToggles.dashboardNewLayouts && !oldModel.meta.isSnapshot ? 'v2' : 'v1';
if (oldModel.meta.isSnapshot) {
variables = createVariablesForSnapshot(oldModel);
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
import { omit } from 'lodash';
import { AnnotationQuery } from '@grafana/data';
import { AnnotationQuery, isEmptyObject, TimeRange } from '@grafana/data';
import { config } from '@grafana/runtime';
import {
behaviors,
@@ -13,7 +13,7 @@ import {
SceneVariableSet,
VizPanel,
} from '@grafana/scenes';
import { DataSourceRef } from '@grafana/schema';
import { DataSourceRef, VariableRefresh } from '@grafana/schema';
import { sortedDeepCloneWithoutNulls } from 'app/core/utils/object';
import {
@@ -497,6 +497,104 @@ export function getDefaultDataSourceRef(): DataSourceRef {
return { type: ds.meta.id, uid: ds.name }; // in the datasource list from bootData "id" is the type
}
export function trimDashboardForSnapshot(title: string, time: TimeRange, dash: DashboardV2Spec, panel?: VizPanel) {
let spec: DashboardV2Spec = {
...dash,
title,
timeSettings: {
...dash.timeSettings,
from: time.from.toISOString(),
to: time.to.toISOString(),
},
links: [],
};
// When VizPanel is present, we are snapshoting a single panel. The rest of the panels is removed from the dashboard,
// and the panel is resized to 24x20 grid and placed at the top of the dashboard.
if (panel) {
const panelId = getPanelIdForVizPanel(panel);
// Find the panel in elements
const panelElementKey = Object.keys(dash.elements || {}).find((key) => {
const element = dash.elements![key];
return element.spec.id === panelId;
});
if (panelElementKey) {
// Keep only this panel in elements
spec.elements = {
[panelElementKey]: dash.elements![panelElementKey],
};
spec.layout = {
kind: 'GridLayout',
spec: {
items: [
{
kind: 'GridLayoutItem',
spec: {
element: {
kind: 'ElementReference',
name: panelElementKey,
},
width: 24,
height: 20,
x: 0,
y: 0,
},
},
],
},
};
}
}
// Remove links from all panels
spec.elements = Object.fromEntries(
Object.entries(spec.elements).map(([key, element]) => {
if ('links' in element) {
element.links = [];
}
return [key, element];
})
);
if (spec.annotations) {
const annotations = spec.annotations.filter((annotation) => annotation.spec.enable) || [];
const trimedAnnotations = annotations.map((annotation): AnnotationQueryKind => {
return {
kind: 'AnnotationQuery',
spec: {
name: annotation.spec.name,
enable: annotation.spec.enable,
iconColor: annotation.spec.iconColor,
builtIn: annotation.spec.builtIn,
hide: annotation.spec.hide,
query: annotation.spec.query,
},
};
});
spec.annotations = trimedAnnotations;
}
if (spec.variables) {
spec.variables.forEach((variable) => {
if ('query' in variable) {
variable.query = '';
}
if ('options' in variable && 'current' in variable) {
variable.options = variable.current && !isEmptyObject(variable.current) ? [variable.current] : [];
}
if ('refresh' in variable) {
variable.refresh = VariableRefresh.never;
}
});
}
return spec;
}
// Function to know if the dashboard transformed is a valid DashboardV2Spec
export function validateDashboardSchemaV2(dash: unknown): dash is DashboardV2Spec {
if (typeof dash !== 'object' || dash === null || Array.isArray(dash)) {
@@ -5,6 +5,7 @@ import { selectors as e2eSelectors } from '@grafana/e2e-selectors';
import { Trans, t } from '@grafana/i18n';
import { getBackendSrv } from '@grafana/runtime';
import { SceneComponentProps, sceneGraph, SceneObjectBase, SceneObjectRef, VizPanel } from '@grafana/scenes';
import { Dashboard } from '@grafana/schema/dist/esm/index.gen';
import { Button, ClipboardButton, Field, Input, Modal, RadioButtonGroup, Stack } from '@grafana/ui';
import { notifyApp } from 'app/core/actions';
import { createSuccessNotification } from 'app/core/copy/appNotification';
@@ -12,8 +13,13 @@ import { getTrackingSource, shareDashboardType } from 'app/features/dashboard/co
import { getDashboardSnapshotSrv, SnapshotSharingOptions } from 'app/features/dashboard/services/SnapshotSrv';
import { dispatch } from 'app/store/store';
import { Spec as DashboardV2Spec } from '../../../../../packages/grafana-schema/src/schema/dashboard/v2';
import { DashboardScene } from '../scene/DashboardScene';
import { transformSceneToSaveModel, trimDashboardForSnapshot } from '../serialization/transformSceneToSaveModel';
import {
transformSceneToSaveModelSchemaV2,
trimDashboardForSnapshot as trimDashboardForSnapshotV2,
} from '../serialization/transformSceneToSaveModelSchemaV2';
import { DashboardInteractions } from '../utils/interactions';
import { SceneShareTabState, ShareView } from './types';
@@ -55,6 +61,12 @@ export interface ShareSnapshotTabState extends SceneShareTabState {
snapshotSharingOptions?: SnapshotSharingOptions;
}
// this is a hacky way to pass the uid with the dashboard to the backend so the dashboard can be found
// and snapshot can be created
interface DashboardV2SpecWithUid extends DashboardV2Spec {
uid?: string;
}
export class ShareSnapshotTab extends SceneObjectBase<ShareSnapshotTabState> implements ShareView {
public tabId = shareDashboardType.snapshot;
static Component = ShareSnapshotTabRenderer;
@@ -102,7 +114,26 @@ export class ShareSnapshotTab extends SceneObjectBase<ShareSnapshotTabState> imp
private prepareSnapshot() {
const timeRange = sceneGraph.getTimeRange(this);
const { dashboardRef, panelRef } = this.state;
const saveModel = transformSceneToSaveModel(dashboardRef.resolve(), true);
let saveModel: Dashboard | DashboardV2SpecWithUid;
const apiVersion = dashboardRef.resolve().serializer.apiVersion;
const isV2Dashboard =
apiVersion === 'dashboard.grafana.app/v2beta1' || apiVersion === 'dashboard.grafana.app/v2alpha1';
if (isV2Dashboard) {
saveModel = transformSceneToSaveModelSchemaV2(dashboardRef.resolve(), true);
saveModel.uid = dashboardRef.resolve().serializer.getK8SMetadata()?.name;
return trimDashboardForSnapshotV2(
this.state.snapshotName.trim() || '',
timeRange.state.value,
saveModel,
panelRef?.resolve()
);
}
saveModel = transformSceneToSaveModel(dashboardRef.resolve(), true);
return trimDashboardForSnapshot(
this.state.snapshotName.trim() || '',
@@ -78,7 +78,7 @@ import {
import { DashboardDataDTO, DashboardDTO } from 'app/types/dashboard';
import { DashboardWithAccessInfo } from './types';
import { isDashboardResource, isDashboardV0Spec, isDashboardV2Resource } from './utils';
import { isDashboardResource, isDashboardV0Spec, isDashboardV2Resource, isDashboardV2Spec } from './utils';
export function ensureV2Response(
dto: DashboardDTO | DashboardWithAccessInfo<DashboardDataDTO> | DashboardWithAccessInfo<DashboardV2Spec>
@@ -94,14 +94,6 @@ export function ensureV2Response(
dashboard = dto.dashboard;
}
const timeSettingsDefaults = defaultTimeSettingsSpec();
const dashboardDefaults = defaultDashboardV2Spec();
const [elements, layout] = getElementsFromPanels(dashboard.panels || []);
// @ts-expect-error - dashboard.templating.list is VariableModel[] and we need TypedVariableModel[] here
// that would allow accessing unique properties for each variable type that the API returns
const variables = getVariables(dashboard.templating?.list || []);
const annotations = getAnnotations(dashboard.annotations?.list || []);
let accessMeta: DashboardWithAccessInfo<DashboardV2Spec>['access'];
let annotationsMeta: DashboardWithAccessInfo<DashboardV2Spec>['metadata']['annotations'];
let labelsMeta: DashboardWithAccessInfo<DashboardV2Spec>['metadata']['labels'];
@@ -154,6 +146,36 @@ export function ensureV2Response(
annotationsMeta[AnnoKeyDashboardSnapshotOriginalUrl] = dashboard.snapshot?.originalUrl;
}
const metadata = {
creationTimestamp: creationTimestamp || '', // TODO verify this empty string is valid
name: dashboard.uid,
resourceVersion: dashboard.version?.toString() || '0',
annotations: annotationsMeta,
labels: labelsMeta,
};
if (!isDashboardResource(dto)) {
if (isDashboardV2Spec(dto.dashboard)) {
// sometimes we can have a v2 spec returned through legacy api like public dashboard
// in that case we need to return dashboard as it is, since the conversion is not needed
return {
apiVersion: 'v2beta1',
kind: 'DashboardWithAccessInfo',
metadata,
spec: dto.dashboard,
access: accessMeta,
};
}
}
const timeSettingsDefaults = defaultTimeSettingsSpec();
const dashboardDefaults = defaultDashboardV2Spec();
const [elements, layout] = getElementsFromPanels(dashboard.panels || []);
// @ts-expect-error - dashboard.templating.list is VariableModel[] and we need TypedVariableModel[] here
// that would allow accessing unique properties for each variable type that the API returns
const variables = getVariables(dashboard.templating?.list || []);
const annotations = getAnnotations(dashboard.annotations?.list || []);
const spec: DashboardV2Spec = {
title: dashboard.title,
description: dashboard.description,
@@ -185,13 +207,7 @@ export function ensureV2Response(
return {
apiVersion: 'v2beta1',
kind: 'DashboardWithAccessInfo',
metadata: {
creationTimestamp: creationTimestamp || '', // TODO verify this empty string is valid
name: dashboard.uid,
resourceVersion: dashboard.version?.toString() || '0',
annotations: annotationsMeta,
labels: labelsMeta,
},
metadata,
spec,
access: accessMeta,
};